Not a critic's list. These are the films that Popcorn members who rated Project Hail Mary highly went on to rate highly themselves, ranked by how strongly the two overlap.

211 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

206 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

136 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

209 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

191 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

171 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

165 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

185 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

180 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

199 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

176 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

155 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

163 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

166 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

136 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

124 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

175 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

126 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

164 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.

141 members who loved Project Hail Mary also rated this highly.
Every Popcorn member rates the films they have seen. When enough of the people who rated Project Hail Mary highly also rate another film highly, that film appears here, and the count next to it is how many of them did. The order is by how strongly the two overlap rather than by the raw count, so a film loved by most of a smaller group can rank above one loved by more people overall. Nobody edits this list and no one can pay to be on it — it changes on its own as people rate.
Rate a few films and Popcorn works out what to put on tonight — matched to your taste, not to what a studio paid to promote.